When the average homeowner thinks about home heating, the furnace is probably the first appliance that comes to mind. But energy efficiency aficionados may think differently because heat pumps -- which operate very differently -- can heat certain homes for a fraction of the energy cost. But which one is right for you?
First, let’s take a look at the basic differences.
How Furnaces and Heat Pumps Work
Most North American homes are heated with some type of forced air furnace, usually powered by gas or electricity. Gas furnaces feature sealed combustion chambers to generate heat, and electric resistance furnaces have electric heating elements similar to those in electric space heaters, only more powerful. In both cases, a fan circulates air over the heating elements and through a network of vents to heat a home.
Forced air heat pumps don’t produce any heat at all -- rather, they pull heat right out of the outside air, even if the air is cold. The heat is then condensed and pumped into the home through a fan system. There’s also another type of heat pump that uses geothermal energy; instead of salvaging heat from outside air, it gets heat from the relatively stable below-ground temperatures using a circuit of buried pipes.
Which One is Right for Your Home?
There are several factors to consider when deciding between a furnace and a heat pump, but the major factor is the climate. In temperate climates with mild winters, heat pumps tend to be significantly more energy-efficient than furnaces. But in frigid temperatures, heat pumps often struggle to keep up. Many systems have an auxiliary heat source that kicks in under these circumstances, but it’s far less efficient than a traditional forced-air furnace.
Geothermal heat pumps are more resilient in colder climates, but they also cost significantly more to install than any other heating option, and there are some locations where the installation is impossible. So the farther north you live, the more likely it is that a good old furnace is the most effective and efficient option.
If you do live in an appropriate climate for a heat pump, there’s another big benefit in addition to the efficiency gains. Heat pumps can also cool your home simply by working in reverse -- they pull hot air from inside the house and pump it outdoors. This allows you to heat and cool your home using a single unit, which can save you a lot when purchasing and installing a new system. It does, however, make maintenance intervals come around a little faster since there’s just one system doing the work all year long.
Review Your Options With a Pro
If you’re not sure which system is right for you, a licensed HVAC technician can help you work through the decision. It’s best to consult experienced professionals about whether your climate is appropriate for a heat pump, as well as the difference between up-front costs and operating costs. In general, the up-front costs of furnaces are lower than forced air heat pumps and much lower than geothermal heat pumps, unless you also need a full duct network installed. But if you’re in a temperate climate, the low operating costs of a heat pump can more than make up the difference over time.
Not sure where to begin? Contact your local One Hour Heating & Air Conditioning for a no-obligation consultation today.